U.S. Naval Observatory Dome Receives A Face-lift

By: Chris Futrick                        Oscar Serrano

      Pentek, Inc.                         Serrano Painting, Inc.

The U.S. Naval Observatory Dome, a few miles west of Flagstaff, Arizona, recently underwent a face-lift to improve the appearance of the exterior of the dome and preserve its structural integrity. The presence of aging coats of lead-containing paint in a public place warranted that the lead paint removal proceed in a manner that was safe both to the environment and to the workers performing the deleading.

US Naval Observatory Dome

The Observatory was established in 1955 and operates three optical telescopes, the largest of which is the 61-inch astrometric reflector. This facility houses the premier ground-based telescopes for the measurement of stellar parallax. The Dome sits over 6,000 feet above sea level and can experience severe weather on occasion (http://www.usno.navy.mil).

Serrano Painting, an Arizona based painting contractor, was contracted to remove 11,000 ft2 of lead-based paint from the exterior of the Dome and to prepare the steel underneath as part of the Dome refurbishment. Serrano Painting was careful in selecting a lead abatement technology for the Observatory Dome project. Serrano looked for a methodology that would specifically eliminate the need for full containment structures--a requisite of traditional coatings removal techniques such as abrasive blasting. These tent-like structures, along with associated air filtration and dust collection equipment, require lengthy set-up and are very costly to maintain. Moreover, if the containment succeeds in protecting the surrounding environment, it increases the potential exposure to the workers operating inside that containment. It was also realized that obstructive containment tenting or visible emissions of dust diffusing from the worksite would earn swift and negative attention. The potential for escaped lead-contaminated air emissions during blasting operations also warrants the use of full facepiece respirators by abatement workers operating in positive-pressure mode.Pentek's VAC-PAC and Corner Cutters

Serrano Painting chose to use a shrouded power tool system designed by Pentek that safely removes lead-based coatings and captures the hazardous airborne dust and debris. These systems have been tested and approved by the Department of Energy (DOE), Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), OSHA, and Housing and Urban Development (HUD). Shrouded power tool technology effectively prepares structural steel for new coatings, while simultaneously controlling all emissions in excess of 99.5 percent. Thus, the need for containment and respirators is eliminated by preventing the potential for lead poisoning to the environment and workers. "Inspectors on-site were so impressed with the systems ability to control emissions that they invited other facility owners to view the removal project", said Serrano.

Shrouded power tools with localized exhaust come in two general types: rotary peening scalers for flat surfaces; and needle guns with adjustable shrouds for tight areas, such as corners, edges, or around bolts. For this project a combination of Roto-Peen Scaler's and Corner-Cutter needle guns were used simultaneously to perform coatings removal on the dome. Coatings were captured at the point of removal and were conveyed via 100 foot vacuum hoses to a centrally located VAC-PAC Multi-tool Waste Collection Unit. One JLG 80-foot man-lift was utilized to support two abatement technicians to access the exposed steel in unreachable elevated areas, while additional workers operated from lower positions. These long distances were not a problem as the operators were able to run hoses sufficient to aid removal operations at a distance of up to 200.

Corner Cutter Shrouded ToolBoth the Roto-Peen Scaler and Corner-Cutter needle gun utilize a mechanical, air-driven process that cleans surfaces to a bare substrate, while the above mentioned VAC-PAC HEPA filtered waste collection unit simultaneously captures dust and debris and transports the waste it into an on-board 55-gallon drum. The VAC-PAC is equipped with several engineering controls built into the system to insure that exposure to hazardous airborne particulate would be minimized. Those features include patented dustless drum changeout procedures, safety interlocks, visual and audible full drum alarms, and onboard gauges that allow you to monitor the performance of the VAC-PAC during operation.Poto-Peen Removes Coatings

Dust-free surface preparation is a viable alternative to abrasive blasting for large industrial structures like domes and bridges. For Serrano, waste minimization, environmental protection, worker safety, and the elimination of other less identifiable liability costs made multi-tool shrouded power tool system an option he could not ignore.

The advent of larger multi-tool systems have provided significant increases in productivity efficiencies by allowing painting or abatement contractors to operate up to 10 shrouded tools as necessary to match or surpass the production rates of an abrasive blast nozzle. Quality power tool systems have established a track record of not only performing reliably within OSHA standards, but often below the detectable range of the monitoring equipment. This strict level of environmental control allows contractors and owners to be more cost-effective by foregoing many of the expensive logistical and regulatory obstacles that are mandatory for traditional lead abatement processes.

[Home] [Lead] [Nuclear & Decon ] [Products] [Customer Service] [Users List] [Case Histories] [Flaps]